Guest viewing is limited

My C2 application and retaliatory application

Fiji107

New member
Member
So I submitted a c2 application a few weeks ago to get disclosure of text messages from my ex. Texts that prove her allegations to be completely false. For months she’s refused to disclose these, knowing full well they are bad for her and that I don’t have them as my phones been seized by police.
In retaliation she’s made a counter application-
1- saying that I’ve already had these messages disclosed by police, I haven’t
2- demanding disclosure of all my communication with the court
3-disclosure of all communications between me and local authority regarding a complaint I made
4-disclosure of all communications between me and SRA regarding a complaint I made about her solicitor
5-disclosure of all communications between me and CAFCASS since the case started.

None of it is relevant to the case whatsoever and along with her statement that claims that I’ve only taken her to court to harass her and “exert controlling and coercive behaviour” against her.

Anyone had any experience of anything like this? I’m not fussed about any of it being disclosed because it doesn’t contain anything that’s false etc but I don’t see how any of it is relevant to child arrangements.
What’s the likelihood of the district judge ordering this?
Plus she’s now demanding another Hair strand test even though ones already been done with a negative result.

Seems to me that she’s defecting from the fact that she’s produced zero evidence to support her allegations that are being heard in a fact find.
 
I am not convinced that she would give true disclosure. It wouldn't be too difficult to cherry pick the messages and protect herself. Would it?

But, if there is nothing harmful in what she is asking for. You could offer to give her what she is asking for in exchange for the texts. This would settle things independent court hearings. In all likelihood she would refuse. In which case you look like the reasonable party.

You could submit a response to her C2 saying you have offered to settle and highlighting that you are requesting disclosure that is central to the issue in question and she has retaliated by asking for disclosure that is immaterial.
 
That’s a good idea to offer to swap. I’m all likelihood she will refuse as she doesn’t want those messages getting out as she knows they completely disprove her claims.
The messages are on WhatsApp. I’ve asked for an exported pdf file which shows times, dates and any messages that are deleted so if she does delete a load of stuff it’ll be glaringly obvious and won’t look good.
I have drafted a position statement which basically says what you’ve suggested in your last paragraph.
 
she has no lawful right to disclosures or communications you have had with cafcass, your solicitor or local authority and not a single court in the land would uphold such a request. If she wants a court transcript she can request it herself. So relax dude she is simply ranting.
 
Back
Top